Penalty Minutes
| MOST PENALTY MINUTES, CAREER |
| 2,807 - Garet Hunt (Stockton; Alaska; Jacksonville; Wheeling; South Carolina - 2009-24) |
| 2,425 - Cam Brown (Baton Rouge; Columbus; Erie; Gwinnett - 1991-93, 1994-2002, 2003-06) |
| 2,253 - Brian Goudie (Hampton Roads; Pee Dee; Richmond; Florida - 1992-2003) |
| 2,246 - Jason Clarke (Charlotte; Erie; Roanoke; Tallahassee; Pensacola; Mobile - 1993-97, 1998-2001 |
| 2,183 - Trevor Senn (Winston-Salem; Wheeling; Greensboro; Richmond; South Carolina - 1991-97, 1998-2000) |
| View top 20 career penalty minutes |
| MOST PENALTY MINUTES, SEASON |
| 512 - Rob McCaig (Louisiana, 1995-96) |
| 507 - Trevor Senn (Richmond, 1995-96) |
| 505 - Kevin Evans (Mississippi, 1996-97) |
| 491 - Jason Clarke (Roanoke, 1995-96) |
| 467 - Jason Clarke (Roanoke, 1994-95) |
| HIGHEST PENALTY MINUTES-PER-GAME AVERAGE, SEASON |
| 10.9 - Link Gaetz (Nashville, 1993-94) |
| 10.4 - Ken Tasker (Toledo, 1999-00) |
| 9.8 - Andy Bezeau (South Carolina, 1993-94) |
| 9.7 - Garrett Burnett (Johnstown, 1997-98) |
| - Trevor Senn (Greensboro/Richmond/South Carolina, 1994-95) |
| MOST PENALTY MINUTES, GAME |
| 62 - Ron Majic (Hampton Roads vs. Wheeling, Feb. 24, 1995) |
| - Greg Capson (Greensboro vs. Raleigh, Feb. 23, 1993) |
| 57 - Brett Angel (Phoenix at Idaho, Feb. 16, 2008) |
| - Jason Hamilton (Greenville vs. Augusta, Nov. 27, 1998) |
| 54 - Travis Tucker (Louisville vs. Columbus, Jan. 5, 1996) |
| MOST MINOR PENALTIES, GAME |
| 8 - four times, most recent: Chris Wheaton, Las Vegas vs. Long Beach, Feb. 15, 2004 |
| MOST MAJOR PENALTIES, GAME |
| 4 - Trevor Senn (Richmond vs. Peoria, March 3, 2000) |
| - Trevor Senn (Richmond vs. Hampton Roads, Dec. 26, 1998) |
| - Eric Boulton (Charlotte vs. Knoxville, Oct. 30, 1996) |