| MOST GOALS, CAREER |
| 370 - Wes Goldie (Pee Dee, Victoria, Alaska - 1999-2012) |
| 368 - Rod Taylor (Hampton Roads, Richmond, Roanoke, South Carolina, Peoria, Toledo - 1991-2003) |
| 325 - Louis Dumont (Tallahassee, Wheeling, Louisiana, Augusta, Pensacola, Mississippi, Utah - 1994-2006) |
| - Trevor Jobe (Hampton Roads, Nashville, Richmond, Raleigh, Johnstown, Tallahassee, Baton Rouge - 1989-99) |
| 323 - Darren Colbourne (Dayton, Richmond, Raleigh, Augusta - 1991-99) |
| 316 - Sheldon Gorski (Louisville, Miami, Pensacola - 1990-99) |
| 313 - Darren Schwartz (Johnstown, Winston-Salem, Wheeling, Tallahassee - 1990-99) |
| 295 - Darryl Noren (Charlotte, Greensboro - 1999-2000) |
| 290 - Justin Taylor (Trenton, Idaho, Tulsa, Kalamazoo, Fort Wayne - 2010-25) |
| 268 - Jay Murphy (Louisiana, Richmond, Greensboro - 1993-2003) |
| 254 - Dany Bousquet (Hampton Roads, Birmingham, Pee Dee - 1995-2002) |
| 251 - Phil Berger (Greensboro, Charlotte, Raleigh, Hampton Roads - 1989-2000) |
| 249 - Allan Sirois (Baton Rouge, Jacksonville, Pee Dee, Greenville, Texas - 1996-2007) |
| 248 - Don Parsons (Nashville, Tallahassee, Johnstown, Baton Rouge, Louisiana - 1991-99) |
| 236 - Randy Rowe (Peoria, Johnstown, Charlotte, Trenton, Toledo - 2001-13) |
| 226 - Jim Bermingham (Toledo, Wheeling, Huntington, Jackson, Pensacola - 1992-2001) |
| - Jason Elders (Mobile - 1995-2002) |
| 225 - Andrew Williamson (Columbus, Dayton, Toledo, Augusta - 1997-2003) |
| 224 - Cail MacLean (Jacksonville, Trenton, Reading, South Carolina - 1997-2008) |
| 221 - Rick Kowalsky (Hampton Roads, Roanoke, Trenton - 1994-2005) |