| MOST GOALS, CAREER |
| 370 - Wes Goldie (Pee Dee, Victoria, Alaska - 1999-2012) |
| 368 - Rod Taylor (Hampton Roads, Richmond, Roanoke, South Carolina, Peoria, Toledo - 1991-2003) |
| 325 - Louis Dumont (Tallahassee, Wheeling, Louisiana, Augusta, Pensacola, Mississippi, Utah - 1994-2006) |
| - Trevor Jobe (Hampton Roads, Nashville, Richmond, Raleigh, Johnstown, Tallahassee, Baton Rouge - 1989-99) |
| 323 - Darren Colbourne (Dayton, Richmond, Raleigh, Augusta - 1991-99) |
| 316 - Sheldon Gorski (Louisville, Miami, Pensacola - 1990-99) |
| 313 - Darren Schwartz (Johnstown, Winston-Salem, Wheeling, Tallahassee - 1990-99) |
| 295 - Darryl Noren (Charlotte, Greensboro - 1999-2000) |
| 279 - Justin Taylor (Trenton, Idaho, Tulsa, Kalamazoo - 2010-24) |
| 268 - Jay Murphy (Louisiana, Richmond, Greensboro - 1993-2003) |
| 254 - Dany Bousquet (Hampton Roads, Birmingham, Pee Dee - 1995-2002) |
| 251 - Phil Berger (Greensboro, Charlotte, Raleigh, Hampton Roads - 1989-2000) |
| 249 - Allan Sirois (Baton Rouge, Jacksonville, Pee Dee, Greenville, Texas - 1996-2007) |
| 248 - Don Parsons (Nashville, Tallahassee, Johnstown, Baton Rouge, Louisiana - 1991-99) |
| 236 - Randy Rowe (Peoria, Johnstown, Charlotte, Trenton, Toledo - 2001-13) |
| 226 - Jim Bermingham (Toledo, Wheeling, Huntington, Jackson, Pensacola - 1992-2001) |
| - Jason Elders (Mobile - 1995-2002) |
| 225 - Andrew Williamson (Columbus, Dayton, Toledo, Augusta - 1997-2003) |
| 224 - Cail MacLean (Jacksonville, Trenton, Reading, South Carolina - 1997-2008) |
| 221 - Rick Kowalsky (Hampton Roads, Roanoke, Trenton - 1994-2005) |
Adirondack Thunder
Allen Americans
Atlanta Gladiators
Bloomington Bison
Cincinnati Cyclones
Florida Everblades
Fort Wayne Komets
Greenville Swamp Rabbits
Idaho Steelheads
Indy Fuel
Iowa Heartlanders
Jacksonville Icemen
Kalamazoo Wings
Kansas City Mavericks
Maine Mariners
Norfolk Admirals
Orlando Solar Bears
Rapid City Rush
Reading Royals
Savannah Ghost Pirates
South Carolina Stingrays
Tahoe Knight Monsters
Toledo Walleye
Trois-Rivières Lions
Tulsa Oilers
Utah Grizzlies
Wheeling Nailers
Wichita Thunder
Worcester Railers